2026 Survey Results for TDSB Trustee Election Candidates

Toronto Palestinian Families (TPF) — 2026 Election

Last updated: October 12, 2026, 08:23 ET | Version 1.6
This page will be updated as responses are received. Check back for the latest version.


Contents


Summary

TPF sent a three-question survey to all TDSB trustee candidates ahead of the October 26, 2026 election. Eighteen candidates responded. Of those, 8 are aligned with TPF’s positions on Palestinian students and curriculum, 2 are mostly aligned, 2 are mixed, 1 mostly opposed, 3 are opposed, 1 responded in comments only and is mixed, and 1 responded in comments only and is opposed. At least one candidate has responded in 11 of 12 wards. Ward 9 is the only ward with no responses so far.

Full responses, including each candidate’s written comments, are shown below. The raw data is linked in Appendix B.


Understanding Ward Numbers: TDSB vs. City of Toronto

When you vote in the 2026 municipal election, you’ll see two different ward systems on your ballot:

City of Toronto Wards (25 total): These are the wards used to elect your City Councillor. There are 25 city wards across Toronto. You can find your city ward and your local candidates on the City of Toronto’s website.

TDSB Trustee Wards (12 total): These are the wards used to elect your school board trustee. In April 2026, the Ontario government passed legislation (Bill 101) that capped school boards at 12 trustees. This reduced the TDSB from 22 trustee wards to 12. The boundaries of these 12 trustee wards are different from the 25 city wards, and each trustee ward covers a larger area that may include multiple city wards.

Candidates in this survey are running for TDSB Trustee, so they are listed by their trustee ward number (1 through 12). If you don’t see a candidate from your city ward listed, it’s because the TDSB trustee ward covering your area may be different from your city ward number.

To find your TDSB trustee ward and see the full list of candidates, visit the City of Toronto’s candidate list: https://www.toronto.ca/city-government/elections/candidate-list/

You can also use the TDSB’s Trustee Wards page to find your specific trustee ward: https://www.tdsb.on.ca/leadership/trustee-wards

Candidate Ratings

WardCandidateRating
1Matias De DovitiisAligned
2Tim EllisAligned
3Fatin IshraqAligned
3Alexis DawsonMixed
4Ivanna AndrusyakMostly Opposed
5Andrene GregoryAligned
5Andrew MasseyMostly Aligned
5Jennifer VolkComments Only (Mixed)
6Sarah SmithiesMostly Aligned
7Shaffni NalirAligned
7Adam GoldingComments Only (Opposed)
8Ibrahim HatiaAligned
10Ahnaaf HassanAligned
10Karen EmersonAligned
11Curtis JackOpposed
11Abdul Azeem MohammedOpposed
12Ketan PurohitOpposed
12Aria Milado GarciaMixed

Methodology: Ratings reflect the candidate’s answers to the three survey questions, including their written comments. “Aligned” means the candidate selected the position most consistent with TPF’s framework on all three questions. “Mostly Aligned” means aligned on two questions or aligned with material caveats. “Mixed” means one aligned answer or unclear positions. “Mostly Opposed” means the candidate took a position contrary to TPF’s framework on at least one question, with other questions left unanswered or answered with the uninformed/commitment option. “Opposed” means the candidate consistently selected positions contrary to TPF’s framework. “Comments Only” means the candidate did not select any of the survey options and instead provided written responses. Where their comments clearly indicate a position, this is noted in parentheses (e.g., “Comments Only (Opposed)”).

Some candidates used the “Other” option to provide their own answers rather than selecting a standard option. These are published as written and rated based on the substance of the response. Where a candidate modified a standard option, this is noted in their entry. Where a candidate did not answer a question, this is noted in their entry. Ratings reflect only the questions they answered.


Full Responses by Ward

Ward 1 — Matias De Dovitiis — Aligned

Q1: I believe Palestinian students must be able to learn about, discuss, and name the ongoing genocide, and I oppose “no politics” policies that are weaponized to disproportionately silence marginalized voices.

Q2: I will maintain my commitment to equity and the safety of Palestinian students, relying on the board’s equity policies rather than caving to external pressure campaigns.

Q3: I reject the IHRA definition due to its weaponization against Palestinian rights. I support adopting the Jerusalem Declaration (JDA) and fully implementing the Patrick Case recommendations, including a distinct, resourced Anti-Palestinian Racism (APR) strategy.

General comment: I have already voted on these issues and will continue to support APR initiative if re-elected.


Ward 2 — Tim Ellis — Aligned

Q1: I believe Palestinian students must be able to learn about, discuss, and name the ongoing genocide, and I oppose “no politics” policies that are weaponized to disproportionately silence marginalized voices.

Comment: There is a clear distinction between antisemitism — which must be opposed in all cases — and opposition to the actions of the nation of Israel. There is no time where antisemitism is acceptable in a classroom or anywhere else, just as there is no time where anti-Palestinian racism or any other bigotry is acceptable. By contrast, frank discussions of the documented actions of the state of Israel, including ongoing illegal occupations, war crimes, and genocidal actions, are relevant to age appropriate educational settings, and also directly inform the lived experiences of some TDSB students, who must be empowered to speak about their lives and the harms that have been inflicted on them. Refugees of hostile occupations, whether they be Ukrainian, Palestinian, or any other, must not be silenced in the name of keeping a false peace.

Q2: I will maintain my commitment to equity and the safety of Palestinian students, relying on the board’s equity policies rather than caving to external pressure campaigns.

Comment: My grandpa was from the north of Ireland. My great grandma had her culture beaten out of her at a residential school. Both fled their homes to survive, which is the only reason I exist. I am the children of peoples who have been the target of genocides and nevertheless endured. I will never forsake that heritage or the responsibility that comes with it: to not only survive myself, but to do everything I can to create a righteous, equitable world where all children can blossom to their full potential without fear and without hate. That is a core value of mine, and no amount of pressure will change my values.

Q3: I reject the IHRA definition due to its weaponization against Palestinian rights. I support adopting the Jerusalem Declaration (JDA) and fully implementing the Patrick Case recommendations, including a distinct, resourced Anti-Palestinian Racism (APR) strategy.

Comment: I have long opposed the IHRA definition due to its conflation (in parts) of antisemitism with criticism of the state of Israel. I was not familiar with the Jerusalem Declaration prior to this survey; on reading it, I found it refreshingly precise and am willing to support its adoption as a working definition of antisemitism going forward. I found the Patrick Case report thorough and fair and am happy to advocate for adopting its recommendations.

General comment: Thank you for organizing for justice and equity. All children deserve to be safe, loved, and welcomed in our schools.


Ward 3

Ward 3 — Fatin Ishraq — Aligned

Q1: I believe Palestinian students must be able to learn about, discuss, and name the ongoing genocide, and I oppose “no politics” policies that are weaponized to disproportionately silence marginalized voices.

Comment: I am committed to Palestinian liberation and advocating for students to learn about and engage with the realities of the genocide, ensuring that Palestinian students are offered safety and accommodations to navigate their mental health. My photography documenting Palestinian social movements in Toronto have been published in the Grind, Canadian Dimension, and Toronto Media Co-op.

Q2: I will maintain my commitment to equity and the safety of Palestinian students, relying on the board’s equity policies rather than caving to external pressure campaigns.

Comment: I am an experienced community organizer and advocate for issues that require me to assert my positions grounding in working class politics. I am aware that intense, organized pressure will seek to challenge my commitment to Palestinian liberation. However, I remain steadfast in my work and will engage with networks and organized movements locally to strategize how we can stay on track to keep all Palestinian students safe and focused on their access to quality public education. As a queer Muslim, it is important for me to navigate safe spaces for all 2SLGBTQ+, Muslim and Palestinian students who remain disproportionately marginalized.

Q3: I reject the IHRA definition due to its weaponization against Palestinian rights. I support adopting the Jerusalem Declaration (JDA) and fully implementing the Patrick Case recommendations, including a distinct, resourced Anti-Palestinian Racism (APR) strategy.

Comment: I support adopting the JDA and a distinct, properly resourced anti-Palestinian racism strategy. My support for the Patrick Case recommendations comes with reservations about the wording of recommendations 1, 3, 7 and 11. Their implementation must distinguish discrimination from political disagreement or discomfort, preserve voluntary and age-appropriate community participation, and avoid unnecessary approval barriers to learning outside the classroom. Restrictions affecting Grassy Narrows attendance should be reviewed with Grassy Narrows First Nation and Indigenous students and families. I visited Grassy Narrows First Nation and lived there for a week while documenting their first ever mercury survivor vigil outside the Dryden paper mill (see: https://fatin-ishraq.format.com/proofing/free-grassy). I am concerned about the proposed restriction on students below Grade 6 attending the Grassy Narrows River Run, which I have attended since 2018. Age-appropriate participation can offer meaningful opportunities to learn about Indigenous histories, rights and ongoing struggles, in keeping with the TRC Calls to Action. Protecting students and enabling meaningful community learning must go together.

General comment: “Ward 3 is my classroom” means learning directly from the students, families, educators and communities our schools serve. Palestinian students should be able to bring their whole selves into school—their histories, culture, grief and hopes—without being silenced or treated with suspicion. As trustee, I will advocate for an anti-Palestinian racism strategy with dedicated resources, staff learning, accessible reporting and accountability. I want to work with Toronto Palestinian Families and Palestinian students to shape that work and assess whether it is making a difference. My community work has taught me that belonging requires relationships and follow-through. Protecting Palestinian students, confronting antisemitism and supporting Indigenous self-determination are commitments we must uphold together. Here are my campaign priorities: build classrooms that work for different minds; empower students with tools to advocate for how they learn; help families navigate education together; put resources where learning happens; build an accessible trustee office. Thank you for the opportunity to share my vision as your Ward 3 TDSB Trustee.


Ward 3 — Alexis Dawson — Mixed

Q1: (Used “Other” — wrote in her own answer) I don’t believe the realities of Gaza and Israel/Palestine should be treated as off-limits simply because they are politically contentious. Students should be able to examine current and historical events through credible evidence, multiple perspectives and critical inquiry, and be supported in forming their own informed views. That learning must also be grounded in human rights, ensuring that every student’s dignity and identity are respected and that all students continue to feel a genuine sense of belonging at school.

Q2: I will maintain my commitment to equity and the safety of Palestinian students, relying on the board’s equity policies rather than caving to external pressure campaigns.

Q3: (Used “Other” — wrote in her own answer) My approach is grounded in human rights and ensuring that all communities are recognized and protected from racism, hate and erasure. I moved a motion calling on the Ministry of Education to implement recommendations from Patrick Case’s Grassy Narrows report, which identified the human-rights-based erasure of Palestinians in and outside schools. My motion also called for mandatory professional learning for trustees and senior leaders on both antisemitism and Palestinian erasure (as per the Case report), and for the TDSB’s work on Anti-Palestinian Racism to be accelerated. On IHRA and the Jerusalem Declaration, I still have more to learn. Before supporting a specific framework, I would want to understand how each definition would operate in schools, hear from affected communities and human-rights experts, and ensure that any approach both protects students from discrimination and preserves space for legitimate discussion and critical inquiry.

Note: Alexis Dawson used written answers for Questions 1 and 3 and selected the aligned option for Question 2. Her Q1 answer frames the issue as balanced critical inquiry rather than centering Palestinian students or naming genocide. Her Q3 answer cites her motion on Patrick Case recommendations and mandatory professional learning on antisemitism and Palestinian erasure, but she has not taken a position on IHRA or the JDA.


Ward 4 — Ivanna Andrusyak — Mostly Opposed

Q1: I am unfamiliar with how “no politics” policies are currently weaponized, but I commit to reviewing TDSB’s equity policies and consulting with impacted students to ensure they are not being silenced. (Selecting this requires a mandatory written explanation of your learning plan).

Comment: It takes a village to raise children. I am educating myself on the issue to make specific changes after listening to kids and parents.

Q2: I would review the complaints to ensure we are remaining “balanced” and not alienating any part of the community, which may mean scaling back or cancelling initiatives.

Q3: (No response provided)

General comment: (No response provided)

Note: Ivanna Andrusyak selected the uninformed/commitment option for Question 1 and the “balanced approach” option for Question 2, which may mean scaling back or cancelling initiatives. She did not provide a response to Question 3. She is rated “Mostly Opposed” because her one substantive position is contrary to TPF’s framework, and she did not take a position on the other two questions.


Ward 5

Ward 5 — Andrene Gregory — Aligned

Q1: I believe Palestinian students must be able to learn about, discuss, and name the ongoing genocide, and I oppose “no politics” policies that are weaponized to disproportionately silence marginalized voices.

Q2: I will maintain my commitment to equity and the safety of Palestinian students, relying on the board’s equity policies rather than caving to external pressure campaigns.

Q3: I reject the IHRA definition due to its weaponization against Palestinian rights. I support adopting the Jerusalem Declaration (JDA) and fully implementing the Patrick Case recommendations, including a distinct, resourced Anti-Palestinian Racism (APR) strategy.

General comment: My goal is to raise the standard of education, quality of care, accountability and opportunity for all.


Ward 5 — Andrew Massey — Mostly Aligned

Q1: I believe Palestinian students must be able to learn about, discuss, and name the ongoing genocide, and I oppose “no politics” policies that are weaponized to disproportionately silence marginalized voices.

Q2: I will maintain my commitment to equity and the safety of Palestinian students, relying on the board’s equity policies rather than caving to external pressure campaigns.

Q3: (Used “Other” — wrote in his own answer) I reject the IHRA definition and would recommend that the TDSB reverse their 2018 decision to adopt it. I would not support adopting the JDA either. I reject the necessity of a definition for this specific form of hate. Instead, I would echo TPFs calls for funded protections and a distinct APR strategy.

Comment: As TPF correctly implies, the IHRA definition does more harm than good and should be rejected. If the true goal is anti-racism, adopting a definition for this specific type of hate is counterproductive. Instead, I would like to see more action focused on critical thinking, media literacy, and community belonging. In this era of AI-generated easy answers, we must inoculate ourselves from destabilizing narratives and reject the politics of division. I think the Patrick Case recommendations have been somewhat overstated in this questionnaire. From my reading, it does not mention the IHRA or the JDA, nor does it call for “a distinct, resourced Anti-Palestinian Racism (APR) strategy” per se. There is also some contradictions. Recommendation #1, for example, appears to sit firmly under the “no politics” banner, which I oppose categorically. Many of its recommendations go beyond the scope of what a trustee can do under provincial supervision; only a handful can be acted upon directly. Trustees could vote on policies that address recommendations 8, 9, 10, and 19, and could directly act on recommendations 17 and 18. Otherwise, these would mainly be set at the staff or provincial level. I wish I could have answered this question more succinctly, but I am not willing to compromise on the importance of nuance when discussing complex topics. I am happy to commit to meeting with TPF and impacted communities to learn more and grow my understanding. Thank you very much for this opportunity.

General comment: As trustee, I have three guiding principles: Fund Schools, Respect Parents, and Build Community. Any action I take as trustee must serve these three principles, and never one at the expense of the others. This is my commitment to you, and to all.

Note: Andrew Massey used the “Other” option for Question 3 and provided his own written answer. He rejects both IHRA and the JDA, and instead supports funded protections and a distinct APR strategy without adopting a definition. He is rated “Mostly Aligned” because he aligns with TPF on Questions 1 and 2 and on key aspects of Question 3 (rejecting IHRA, supporting APR), but diverges on the JDA and expresses reservations about the Patrick Case recommendations.


Ward 5 — Jennifer Volk — Comments Only (Mixed)

Q1: (No option selected) I believe it is the job of the TDSB Trustee to ensure the Ontario Human Rights Code is applied to all students. For me, this means teaching students to engage with difficult, current events critically and with care. It means protecting students’ and staff’s right to name the suffering of Palestinians and to speak about Palestinian identity without being labelled as hateful. This also means acting firmly against antisemitism, Islamophobia, and anti-Palestinian racism, because hate speech and harassment are never free speech. Finally, I believe this means giving staff the training and clear guidance to facilitate these conversations safely, as the Case report recommended.

Q2: (No option selected) When it comes to equity initiatives, it is my intention to make decisions based on evidence, the Ontario Human Rights Code, and the Education Act not organized pressure. I believe that Palestinian students have the same right as every other student to see their identity affirmed, to gather, and to express their views. Any limits on student events or expression must rely on a fair and consistent standard; such as real safety concerns or hate speech. These decisions simply can’t rest on discomfort with a viewpoint or on outside campaigns. For further clarity, I believe the same standard protects Jewish students from antisemitism and every student from harassment. Looking forward, when pressure comes, I can commit that I’ll ask for facts and consider those being impacted before acting.

Q3: (No option selected) While I think the Ontario Human Rights code, when applied consistently and in the spirit it was adopted should protect all students, I am open to specialized policies such as the APR, as long as those policies do all of the following: They must clearly identify hate and discrimination against Palestinians and Jewish people as people and they absolutely must protect students’ and staff’s right to discuss human rights, history, and current events, including criticism of any government. Finally, they must be applied consistently, so that no group’s identity or political views are treated as inherently suspect. These policies must be based in the Ontario Human Rights Code. Students deserve policies that keep them safe without silencing them. We saw in the Case report how avoiding these difficult conversations actually leaves students and educators feeling isolated and less safe.

General comment: Good policies are worth very little without the accompanying resources. The TDSB simply won’t be able to do the statistical tracking, transparent reporting or be adequately responsive and certainly not preventative without the funding to do so. This is one of the many reasons I believe the first responsibility of a Trustee in this current climate is to push back against Doug Ford’s deep cuts to our education system. Our students deserve to be safe at school and that takes resources.

Note: Jennifer Volk did not select any of the survey options. She provided written responses to each question. Her comments invoke strong human-rights principles and affirm Palestinian students’ right to speak about their identity, but they do not commit to specific positions on “no politics” policies, the IHRA/JDA question, or a distinct, resourced APR strategy. She is rated “Comments Only (Mixed)” because her principles are broadly consistent with TPF’s framework but her answers are framed as general commitments rather than specific ones.


Ward 6 — Sarah Smithies — Mostly Aligned

Q1: (Used “Other” — wrote in her own answer) I believe that Palestinian students and their peers (all students) must be able to learn about, discuss, and name the ongoing genocide, and I oppose “no politics” policies.

Q2: I will maintain my commitment to equity and the safety of Palestinian students, relying on the board’s equity policies rather than caving to external pressure campaigns.

Q3: (Used “Other” — wrote in her own answer) I am in favour of addressing Anti-Palestinian Racism with a well-resourced anti-racism and anti-hate strategy. I oppose adopting the IHRA definition of antisemitism, and I commit to meeting with the TPF and impacted communities and to learn more about the JDA.

Comment: I added ‘well-resourced’, as policies and frameworks are not enough without the resources to fulfill them.

General comment: The crisis facing Toronto schools is the result of deliberate, sustained underfunding. Since 2018, the Ford government has cut over $6.5 billion dollars from Ontario school, that’s over $3100 per student. These cuts led to a poorer quality of education, schools in a desperate state of disrepair, and increased violence in our schools. Commitments to inclusion, equity, anti-discrimination, and anti-racism without adequate resources to support it, are hollow. We must fight to restore the resources that have been rolled back, and for an expansion of programs to meet the actual needs of students. Funds for education are not an expense, but an investment in our future. When parents, educators, and trustees pushed back against these cuts Ford’s response was a direct Provincial takeover of the TDSB. I have both a child and grandchild who are current students at the TDSB and I see first-hand how these cuts are affecting their education. This is a funding crisis, not a spending crisis, but it is not too late to build a broad coalition focused on pushing back. While the role of the trustee is to listen to the community, advocate for families, students, and educators, given the current crisis, the role of the trustee must include a commitment to fighting for fair, equitable, well-funded public education across the ward and across the city.

Note: Sarah Smithies used the “Other” option for Questions 1 and 3 and provided her own written answers. Her Q1 answer is close to the aligned option but omits the clause about “no politics” policies being weaponized to silence marginalized voices. Her Q3 answer opposes IHRA, supports resourced APR, and commits to learning about the JDA rather than endorsing it. She is rated “Mostly Aligned” because her positions are broadly consistent with TPF’s framework but not identical to the standard aligned option on all three questions.


Ward 7

Ward 7 — Shaffni Nalir — Aligned

Q1: I believe Palestinian students must be able to learn about, discuss, and name the ongoing genocide, and I oppose “no politics” policies that are weaponized to disproportionately silence marginalized voices.

Comment: APR needs to be brought to the agenda. It’s unfortunate how other school boards have been able to adopt it but tdsb not just refuses to adopt but even doesn’t allow a workshop on it.

Q2: I will maintain my commitment to equity and the safety of Palestinian students, relying on the board’s equity policies rather than caving to external pressure campaigns.

Comment: the alphabet organizations who are a reason for allowing children literally being beaten up or bullied for even wearing a keffiyah will not have an ear or an ounce of my attention (in sha Allah)

Q3: I reject the IHRA definition due to its weaponization against Palestinian rights. I support adopting the Jerusalem Declaration (JDA) and fully implementing the Patrick Case recommendations, including a distinct, resourced Anti-Palestinian Racism (APR) strategy.

Comment: Same comments as question 1.

General comment: Islamophobia and APR are things I have been advocating for the past two years, outside of being a trustee. I have mentioned this to many people whether I win or not I will continue this advocacy. It relates directly to me and the people I serve. That being said of course the platform is helpful.


Ward 7 — Adam Golding — Comments Only (Opposed)

Note: Adam Golding did not select any of the survey options. His written comments reject the JDA, describe antizionism as a form of racism, and question the term “genocide.” These positions are contrary to TPF’s framework on Questions 1 and 3. He is rated “Comments Only (Opposed)” to reflect both the format of his response and the substance of his comments. His full responses are available in the raw data in Appendix B.

Q1: (No option selected)

Comment: I support inter-faith dialogue at the school board level but have called upon all places of worship to lead the way in holding genuine inter-faith dialogue, which is exceedingly rare. [Followed by a long essay on two-state solutions, antizionism, and related topics.]

Q2: (No option selected)

Comment: I am pretty much a free-speech absolutist. [Followed by discussion of free speech, bubble zones, and teaching.]

Q3: (No option selected)

Comment: My understanding is that anti-Palestinian racism in schools is under-reported. I do not think changing the definition of racism addresses this problem of under-reporting. [Followed by a long essay on IHRA, JDA, APR, and related topics.]

General comment: [Long statement including policy positions on recess, arts, class size, coding, inter-faith panels, and links to his Substack.]


Ward 8 — Ibrahim Hatia — Aligned

Q1: I believe Palestinian students must be able to learn about, discuss, and name the ongoing genocide, and I oppose “no politics” policies that are weaponized to disproportionately silence marginalized voices.

Q2: I will maintain my commitment to equity and the safety of Palestinian students, relying on the board’s equity policies rather than caving to external pressure campaigns.

Q3: (Used “Other” — wrote in his own answer) I oppose adopting the IHRA definition and support adopting the Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism. I support implementing the Patrick Case recommendations. Separately, I support a distinct, properly funded strategy addressing anti-Palestinian racism.

General comment: I stand with Palestinian families. My priorities are student safety, protection from discrimination, fair access to education, and meaningful participation by students and families in decisions affecting their schools.

Note: Ibrahim Hatia used the “Other” option for Question 3 and provided his own written answer. His answer rejects IHRA, supports the JDA, supports implementing the Patrick Case recommendations, and supports a distinct, funded APR strategy — substantively matching the aligned position on all four components. He is rated “Aligned.”


Ward 10

Ward 10 — Ahnaaf Hassan — Aligned

Q1: I believe Palestinian students must be able to learn about, discuss, and name the ongoing genocide, and I oppose “no politics” policies that are weaponized to disproportionately silence marginalized voices.

Comment: I believe there needs to be guidelines in place to keep students safe, while also discussing the ongoing genocide. A “no politics” approach only creates barriers, as these issues are a reality for some families in the TDSB. While having guidelines for student safety, we can’t ban these conversations from classrooms.

Q2: I will maintain my commitment to equity and the safety of Palestinian students, relying on the board’s equity policies rather than caving to external pressure campaigns.

Q3: I reject the IHRA definition due to its weaponization against Palestinian rights. I support adopting the Jerusalem Declaration (JDA) and fully implementing the Patrick Case recommendations, including a distinct, resourced Anti-Palestinian Racism (APR) strategy.

General comment: Hatred in any form is not welcome in TDSB schools. However, banning conversations surrounding Palestinian identity and real world issues isn’t the answer. Having these conversations about what is going on in Gaza and the West Bank is part of the conversation around world issues, and by setting guidelines to make sure these conversations are constructive and educational, we educate students while keeping APR and anti-semitism far away from classrooms.


Ward 10 — Karen Emerson — Aligned

Q1: I believe Palestinian students must be able to learn about, discuss, and name the ongoing genocide, and I oppose “no politics” policies that are weaponized to disproportionately silence marginalized voices.

Comment: On May 21, 2025, the elected Board directed that the timeline for addressing Anti-Palestinian Racism under the TDSB’s Anti-Hate and Anti-Racism Strategy be accelerated and that a strategy work plan be brought to the Board for approval by October 2025. However, following the Ministry of Education’s decision to place the TDSB under supervision in June 2025, it seems that Board meeting did not occur. Having now looked into this matter I will be asking the Supervisor and the Minister what work has been completed since May 2025 to implement that direction. [Followed by specific questions about the APR work plan, consultations, and timeline.]

Q2: I will maintain my commitment to equity and the safety of Palestinian students, relying on the board’s equity policies rather than caving to external pressure campaigns.

Comment: Equity isn’t much of a commitment if we abandon it the moment it becomes controversial. Public Education must be designed to help young people become thoughtful participants in a democratic society. That requires opportunities to discuss difficult issues, organize, disagree, question institutions and advocate for causes they believe in. I believe that Anti-Palestinian racism is unacceptable, Antisemitism is unacceptable. Islamophobia is unacceptable. Threats, harassment, and the targeting of students because of their identity are unacceptable. Those standards should apply equally. But protecting Jewish students from antisemitism cannot require silencing Palestinian students, just as protecting Palestinian students cannot mean tolerating antisemitism. A human-rights framework should be capable of doing both. However, the biggest barrier to ensuring the rights of Palestinian’s can be protected both in schools, and in the community is the problematic definitions of what constitutes antisemitism that we are operating with. Prime Minister Carneys affirmation of the IHRA in June 2026 has undermined efforts to address this issue. Until we adopt the JDA in the TDSB and in all levels of government, standing up for Palestinians rights and protecting Palestinian students will continue to be perceived as antisemitism and reported as such in the media putting students and Palestinian’s everywhere at risk. We need to adopt the JDA and fully implement the Patrick Case recommendations in the TDSB. We must ensure more education of staff and students takes place immediately so that our human rights frameworks can actually protect all students. We must also make changes to the Anti-hate portal so that students can report specifically on anti-Palestinian hate in a way that feels safe for them.

Q3: I reject the IHRA definition due to its weaponization against Palestinian rights. I support adopting the Jerusalem Declaration (JDA) and fully implementing the Patrick Case recommendations, including a distinct, resourced Anti-Palestinian Racism (APR) strategy.

General comment: Thank you for taking the time to ensure Trustees are aware of the issues facing Palestinian students and for sharing these important resources. I was very alarmed last year when the permit for workshops on anti-Palestinian racism was withdrawn by the TDSB. In fact this incident and the media’s irresponsible actions after the Grassy Narrows trip were the reasons I started to consider becoming a Trustee. I look forward to meeting people in your community to learn more and to provide any support I can on making our schools and our communities safer for Palestinians. There is so much education to be done and schools are a critical place for this work to begin for young people.


Ward 11

Ward 11 — Curtis Jack — Opposed

Q1: I think we need a balanced approach where multiple perspectives on the conflict can be taught, but extreme rhetoric should be limited.

Comment: Trustees do not have power over the curriculum so this is a bit of a catch 22 question. Trustees can advocate, and vote on certain items and issues, however when it comes down to what is taught, that is not in the purview of a trustee.

Q2: I would review the complaints to ensure we are remaining “balanced” and not alienating any part of the community, which may mean scaling back or cancelling initiatives.

Q3: I support combating all forms of hate and rely on the board’s current general human rights policies rather than adopting specific new definitions or frameworks.

Comment: I would advocate for anti-semitism, anti-Palistinian racism in the same way that I would advocate against anti-Chinese or anti-black racism (as a person of colour myself) I would combat racism in any form.

General comment: Truth be told, I would advocate on behalf of any marginalized community, it’s the fundamental reason I’m running. The continually changing face of this city and this ward can only be strengthened through diverse perspectives, views and fair learning opportunities for children of all races, colours and creeds. Education is a great equalizer, and the only way for it to be successful is for our youth to have access to education free from extreme political views, biased opinions and rhetoric. Schools need to be safe spaces for youth to expand their understanding of the world as we know it, and prepare for the future in which they will inevitably take ownership of.


Ward 11 — Abdul Azeem Mohammed — Opposed

Q1: I think we need a balanced approach where multiple perspectives on the conflict can be taught, but extreme rhetoric should be limited.

Q2: I would review the complaints to ensure we are remaining “balanced” and not alienating any part of the community, which may mean scaling back or cancelling initiatives.

Q3: I support combating all forms of hate and rely on the board’s current general human rights policies rather than adopting specific new definitions or frameworks.

General comment: I am more for a balanced approach under the Canadian Charter of Rights that includes justice for all.


Ward 12

Ward 12 — Ketan Purohit — Opposed

Q1: I support banning “political” discussions to maintain neutrality, avoid controversy, and ensure classrooms remain safe spaces free from external conflicts.

Q2: I would review the complaints to ensure we are remaining “balanced” and not alienating any part of the community, which may mean scaling back or cancelling initiatives.

Q3: I support combating all forms of hate and rely on the board’s current general human rights policies rather than adopting specific new definitions or frameworks.

General comment: [Long statement about Canada as a welcoming country, the importance of unity, academic excellence, equal opportunity, financial responsibility, and community partnership. Argues that conflicts from other parts of the world should not divide Canadian communities.]


Ward 12 — Aria Milado Garcia — Mixed

Q1: I believe Palestinian students must be able to learn about, discuss, and name the ongoing genocide, and I oppose “no politics” policies that are weaponized to disproportionately silence marginalized voices.

Comment: As part of History subject taught in Secondary Schools of TDSB, Gaza Israel is treated the same with other countries who suffered during World Ward 1 & 11 with Japanese occupation and Wordl War 111 COVID pandemic.

Q2: I will maintain my commitment to equity and the safety of Palestinian students, relying on the board’s equity policies rather than caving to external pressure campaigns.

Comment: Palestinians are supported financially by the government if there are Palestines who pay income taxes to the government and or there are Palestinians who run as government officials during Federal and Provincial elections. If none, it is hard to promote Palestine programs without investments by Israel to Canada or tax payment from Palestine family to the government.

Q3: I support combating all forms of hate and rely on the board’s current general human rights policies rather than adopting specific new definitions or frameworks.

Comment: Its a matter of choice by the Jewish students to stay in Canada even if there are very few of them and therefore Jewish students should apply for permanent resident visa until they become Canadian citizens. Once you become Canadian citizens, you wont feel any hate to the Canada government because your loyalty rests with Canada. They, you try to help your fellow Jews to become Canadians.

General comment: Similar to Jesus who was an immigrant in Italy and suffered the tyranny of Romans but became the King of Jews and Catholics around the world, we as Catholics and non-Catholics should try to empathize and sympathize other people who suffer because of our desire to become immigrants of other countries.


Non-Responders

The following candidates did not respond to the survey by the deadline. They are listed as “did not respond.”

Here is the table of candidates who did not respond, based on the full candidate list and the 12 responses received. It is grouped by ward for readability.

WardCandidate
1Amberley Ryan Henry
1Antonius Clarke
1Dennis Hastings
1Lakhan Kang
1Rosemarie Bryan
2Ivan Voitsytskyi
2Matthew Zaffino
3Andrew Waters
3Christina Gural
3Daniel Choi
3Jennifer Webster
3Justin Mensah
3Matt Banninga
4Anthony Delpero
4Brandon Choi
4Weidong Pei
5David Gulyas
5Elina Feyginberg
5Gus Stefanis
5Janine Viret
5Jared Kolb
5Maureen Larkin
6John Vassal
6Saherla Osman
6Stacey Cline
7Axel Arvizu
7Deborah Williams
7Gladstone Cherrington
7Nasir Mohammad
7Tasha Kheiriddin
7Theo Nazary
8Christine McGirr
8Dewitt Lee III
8Farzana Rajwani
8Imran Khan
8Spiros Kapoglis
8Tracey Haddleton
9Bill Wu
9Carey De Pass
9Christopher Mammoliti
9Sonny Yeung
10Azim Dewan
10Glenn Kremp
10Jocelyne Poirier
10Malik Ahmad
10Marisa Sterling
10Md Sazibul Islam
10Shawn Li
11Angus Grant
11Dameon Halstead
11Dedan Deus
11Ravicha Ravinthiran
12Anu Sriskandarajah
12Darren Frake
12Gary McBean
12Marcia Wilson
12Safiya Ansari
12Sherri Williams
12Vimuththan Nantheeswarar

Note: This list will be updated as responses are received.


Appendix A: Survey Questions and Options

The following are the resources given for context, questions and options as they appeared in the survey sent to candidates.

Resources Provided to Candidates

Before answering the survey, candidates were given links to the following primary documents. The text below is reproduced as it appeared in the survey. The candidates were encouraged, but not required, to review them.

The Patrick Case Report (2024)
An independent review commissioned by the Ontario Ministry of Education and conducted by Patrick Case, former Assistant Deputy Minister and Director of Equity at the Ministry. The review examined the Toronto District School Board’s field trip policies and procedures following the September 18, 2024 excursion to the Grassy Narrows River Run. The report was submitted on December 30, 2024, and released publicly in April 2025. It includes recommendations related to field trip approval, student safety, and the political controversies that arose around the event.
🔗 Final Report: Review of the TDSB’s Excursions Policy and Procedure

The IHRA Working Definition of Antisemitism
A non-legally binding working definition adopted by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) on May 26, 2016. The core definition states: “Antisemitism is a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred toward Jews. Rhetorical and physical manifestations of antisemitism are directed toward Jewish or non-Jewish individuals and/or their property, toward Jewish community institutions and religious facilities.” The IHRA text includes eleven illustrative examples, several of which relate to the State of Israel.
🔗 IHRA Working Definition of Antisemitism

The Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism (JDA)
A framework launched on March 25, 2021, developed by scholars in Holocaust history, Jewish studies, and Middle East studies. The JDA provides a core definition, a preamble, and fifteen guidelines. It was written as an alternative to the IHRA definition, stating that the IHRA definition is “unclear in key respects and widely open to different interpretations.” The JDA aims to clarify what constitutes antisemitism while protecting space for open debate about Israel and Palestine.
🔗 Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism

Anti-Palestinian Racism (APR)
A framework developed by the Arab Canadian Lawyers Association (ACLA). The ACLA describes anti-Palestinian racism as “a form of anti-Arab racism that silences, excludes, erases, stereotypes, defames or dehumanizes Palestinians or their narratives.” The ACLA report explains how APR operates to silence discourse on Palestine and outlines its impacts on individuals and communities.
🔗 ACLA: Anti-Palestinian Racism – Naming, Framing and Manifestations

Question 1: The “No Politics” Trap & Curriculum

Prompt: School boards frequently face demands to keep “politics” out of the classroom. How do you view the role of the TDSB in addressing the ongoing genocide in Gaza and the realities of Israel/Palestine?

  • I support banning “political” discussions to maintain neutrality, avoid controversy, and ensure classrooms remain safe spaces free from external conflicts.
  • I believe Palestinian students must be able to learn about, discuss, and name the ongoing genocide, and I oppose “no politics” policies that are weaponized to disproportionately silence marginalized voices.
  • I think we need a balanced approach where multiple perspectives on the conflict can be taught, but extreme rhetoric should be limited.
  • I am unfamiliar with how “no politics” policies are currently weaponized, but I commit to reviewing TDSB’s equity policies and consulting with impacted students to ensure they are not being silenced. (Selecting this requires a mandatory written explanation of your learning plan).
  • Other (Provide a comment)

Question 2: Power Dynamics & Organized Pressure

Prompt: Well-funded external advocacy groups frequently pressure school boards to defund equity initiatives, cancel pro-Palestine student events, or restrict student expression. When you face intense, organized pressure to roll back support for Palestinian students, how will you respond?

  • I will maintain my commitment to equity and the safety of Palestinian students, relying on the board’s equity policies rather than caving to external pressure campaigns.
  • I would likely defer to the board’s legal counsel and senior administration to manage the controversy and minimize the board’s public exposure.
  • I would review the complaints to ensure we are remaining “balanced” and not alienating any part of the community, which may mean scaling back or cancelling initiatives.
  • I have not yet faced this level of organized political pressure, but I commit to building relationships with Palestinian community groups now so I have a strong foundation to stand on when the pressure comes. (Selecting this requires a mandatory written explanation).
  • Other (Provide a comment)

Question 3: Frameworks of Hate (IHRA vs. APR & Patrick Case)

Prompt: How will you approach the board’s policies regarding antisemitism, Anti-Palestinian Racism (APR), and the specific frameworks used to define them?

  • I fully support adopting the IHRA definition of antisemitism to protect Jewish students, and I believe APR is adequately covered under existing, general anti-racism frameworks.
  • I reject the IHRA definition due to its weaponization against Palestinian rights. I support adopting the Jerusalem Declaration (JDA) and fully implementing the Patrick Case recommendations, including a distinct, resourced Anti-Palestinian Racism (APR) strategy.
  • I support combating all forms of hate and rely on the board’s current general human rights policies rather than adopting specific new definitions or frameworks.
  • I am not fully versed in the differences between the IHRA, the JDA, and the Patrick Case report, but I commit to meeting with TPF and impacted communities to understand how to properly resource APR. (Selecting this requires a mandatory written explanation).
  • Other (Provide a comment)

Question 4: General Comments

Prompt: Please share any additional statements or comments or goals you have as a trustee.


Appendix B: Raw Data

The complete raw data from this survey is available for public review. It includes every candidate’s verbatim responses, including all checkbox selections, per-question comments, and general comments.

🔗 View the raw data (Google Sheet)

Important note: The raw data contains candidates’ words exactly as submitted. Some responses include language that readers may find offensive, confusing, or contrary to TPF’s positions. TPF does not endorse the content of any candidate’s response. The raw data is published for transparency so that community members can review the full record and draw their own conclusions.

The raw data includes each candidate’s campaign contact email as provided in their survey response. Personal email addresses used only to sign in to the form have been removed. The data is published for transparency so that community members can review the full record and draw their own conclusions.


About This Survey

TPF sent this survey to all TDSB trustee candidates ahead of the October 26, 2026 municipal election. The survey asked three questions about issues affecting Palestinian students, parents, and allies in the TDSB. Candidates were given the option to provide written comments on each question and a general comment at the end.

Responses are published verbatim, with minor formatting edits for readability. Ratings are based on the candidate’s answers to the three questions, including their written comments. Full methodology is available at the top of this page.

If you believe your response has been misrepresented, please contact us.

Last updated: October 12, 2026, 08:23 ET | Version 1.6
This page will be updated as responses are received. Check back for the latest version.